BIBA
GeoTrust
container image

[ Contact Us ]

Need Help? Calling from a mobile please call 0151 647 7556

0800 195 4926

Do you have a question? or need help?

Call Monday-Friday 9am - 6pm Closed Saturday & Sunday,

0800 195 4926

Call Monday-Friday 9am - 6pm Closed Saturday & Sunday

Best Tyre Insurance? What to Look For Before You Buy

 

Quick Summary:

There is no single “best” tyre insurance policy for everyone. The right policy depends on your tyre costs, how often you drive, and what matters most to you (replacement limit, claims per year, excess and eligibility). Below is a practical checklist of what to compare, and how our Tyre Insurance cover measures up.

 

Looking to buy the best tyre insurance policy?

 

If you search for “best tyre insurance”, you will find many suppliers making bold claims. In reality, the best policy for one driver may not be the best for another. A better approach is to compare policies using clear, practical criteria, and then decide what fits your vehicle and budget.

 

This guide explains what typically makes a strong tyre insurance policy and links you to the key product details so you can make a fair comparison. You can also view our Tyre Insurance cover here: Tyre Insurance.

 

This answer is more complex than you may first think

Some drivers prioritise a higher replacement limit per tyre. Others care most about the number of claims per year, the excess structure, or whether the policy can be purchased later (rather than only soon after buying the vehicle).

 

Key Features of Tyre Insurance cover from Total Loss GAP

  • Up to £400 per replacement tyre (as shown on your policy schedule)
  • Up to 5 claims per policy year (claims do not roll into the next year)
  • Up to 3 years of cover available
  • £10 excess applies per repair (waived where a call-out charge is paid for that repair)
  • Up to £50 per puncture repair (including VAT), where the tyre can be safely repaired
  • Can be purchased at any time, provided your vehicle meets eligibility criteria at the start of cover

 

What makes a tyre insurance policy “best” for you?

Use the questions below as a quick comparison checklist before purchasing any policy:

  • Replacement limit: What is the maximum amount payable per tyre, and is it enough for your tyre size/brand?
  • Claims per year: How many claims can you make in a policy year, and do unused claims roll over?
  • Policy term: How long does cover run for, and does it match how long you plan to keep the vehicle?
  • Excess and call-out: Is there an excess per claim/repair, and how do call-out charges work?
  • Eligibility: Can you buy the policy later, or is there a time limit after buying the car?
  • Repairs vs replacement: Does the policy contribute to puncture repairs, and what is the limit?
  • Exclusions: What is not covered (for example, wear and tear, low tread depth, pre-existing damage)?
  • Claims process: Do you need authorisation before repairs and what evidence is required?
  • Underwriter and regulation: Who underwrites the cover and is the seller FCA authorised and regulated?

 

How our Tyre Insurance cover compares (summary)

Based on the criteria above, our Tyre Insurance policy offers a combination of a higher replacement limit and a higher number of claims per policy year than many standard dealership-style policies, with the flexibility to purchase cover later (subject to eligibility).

 

Full terms, limits and exclusions are set out on the product page and in the policy documents: See Tyre Insurance from Total Loss GAP.

 

Eligibility flexibility – can you buy later?

Many tyre insurance policies must be purchased within a short period after buying your vehicle. This policy can be purchased at any time, provided your vehicle meets the eligibility criteria at the start of cover.

  • Vehicle up to 10 years old at start
  • Up to 100,000 miles at start
  • Tyre size up to and including 21 inches
  • Electric vehicles are eligible (subject to criteria)

 

Do not ignore exclusions

The best tyre insurance policies are clear about what is not covered. Common exclusions include wear and tear, pre-existing damage, tyres below a minimum tread depth, cosmetic damage that does not render the tyre unsafe, and repairs carried out without prior authorisation (except emergencies, subject to policy conditions). Always review the IPID and policy wording before purchase.

 

Underwriter strength and regulation

Tyre Insurance from Total Loss GAP is underwritten by Helvetia Global Solutions Ltd (UK Branch). Helvetia is described as an ‘A’ rated insurer on our underwriters and plan providers page, along with further information: Underwriters and plan providers.

Total Loss GAP is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the United Kingdom (FRN 821163).

 

Get a quote and compare

If your vehicle meets the eligibility criteria, you can obtain an instant quote online and compare the features with other policies available to you: Get a Tyre Insurance quote.

Please review the IPID and full policy wording before purchase to ensure the cover meets your needs.

 

You may also like: Tyre Insurance, is it worth it? 

 

Reviewed by
Mark Griffiths, Founding Director and Insurance expert
Last reviewed: 21st February 2026